Cathryn Caroline Fayard

The Queen of Hyperbole Gambles on Becoming Louisiana's

Second in Command — And She Is No Bobby Jindal!

In running her 2010 campaign for Lieutenant Governor of Louisiana, Caroline Fayard lists honesty as one of the attributes she will bring to the position.1  As candidate, she has invited the public to examine what they might expect if elected to that high political post.  Following, are three claims made directly by her or by her campaign, and readers can judge for themselves whether they misrepresent the facts.

Claim A:

"I am the same age as Bobby Jindal the first time he ran for Governor."2, 3

Fayard, 32, reminds everyone that she is the same age that Bobby Jindal was at his first, unsuccessful, campaign for Governor, and she says that her life experiences and background are similar to his at that point, implying that they qualify her to be Lieutenant Governor.2, 3

Unlike Fayard, by the time Jindal had reached the age of 32, he had already held important political positions in Washington, D.C. and Baton Rouge.  At 24, he was appointed by Louisiana Governor Mike Foster to the post of Secretary, Department of Health and Hospitals in Louisiana,4, 5 and at 27, he was appointed President of the eight-campus University of Louisiana college system,5, 6 a post that he held until 2001, when he was nominated by President George W. Bush to be Assistant Secretary of Health and Human Services for Planning and Evaluation.  He resigned from that position in 2003 to campaign for Governor.  Following that unsuccessful campaign, Jindal, at age 33, was elected to Congress and served two terms before running successfully in 2007 to become Louisiana's Governor.5

The positions occupied by Jindal carried executive responsibilities and provided political experience of the type that fully prepared him to lead the state as Governor.  In contrast, Fayard, as Lieutenant Governor—and first in the line of succession to the Governor—has had no experience that is even closely comparable to Jindal's.

Claim B:

"She ... worked in both the White House and Congress..."7, 8

At the age of 16, Fayard was a congressional page in the Clinton administration, sponsored by Representative Billy Tauzin.  By 1997, she had worked her way up to become head intern to Hillary Clinton's Social Secretary.9, 10  Members of the Fayard family had contributed $4,000 to Tauzin's reelection campaign in 1994-95.11

Claim C:

"She ... was later appointed to the faculty of Loyola University, New Orleans, College of Law and served there until 2009."7, 8

In 2007, Fayard received a two-year Westerfield fellowship as a "Writing Fellow" which entailed limited teaching duties to first-year law students.  The fellowship was primarily designed to provide an opportunity for "scholarly writing and publication."12, 13  Her mother, Cynthia Felder Fayard, is a member of the Society of St. Ignatius, whose members support Loyola University of New Orleans with individual lifetime giving of between $100,000 and $1 million.14

A Penchant for Gambling

Fayard's Financial Disclosure Form for Lt. Governor reveals a variety of ownership interests in real estate and other businesses that include gambling.15  Her filing "shows nearly $32,000 in income [in 2009] from video poker truck stop investments: Paxtor Inc. and Safari Investments, LLC, both in Hammond."15  She is an officer of Safari together with Chalyn Cynthia Fayard (her sister) and Robert A. Maurin, III (her first cousin once removed).15  Safari currently owns 20% of Lucky Dollar Casino, which shares Video Poker License No. 4701512880 with T & D Ventures, LLC, also doing business as Lucky Dollar Casino.15, 16, 17

Other business interests of Fayard's include Andante, LLC, Arbor Towne, LLC, and Felyard Investment Group, LLC, of which she is an officer, and Calvin C. Fayard, III (her brother) is agent.15, 18

The Money Go-Round

The head of the Fayard family is Caroline Fayard's father, Calvin C. Fayard, Jr., a prominent Louisiana attorney.  Her step-mother, Frances Gray Fayard, is also an attorney.  Political fundraising has been one of the Fayard family's favorite activities, and former President Bill Clinton and Hillary Rodham Clinton are among those who have benefited from the family's largesse, for which the Clintons in later years expressed their gratitude by supporting Caroline Fayard's political aspirations.  Frances Gray Fayard's home state, like Bill Clinton's, is Arkansas.  She had worked in the Clinton administration as Frances Gray.19

Bill Clinton and the Clinton-Gore '96 Primary Committee PAC each received $1,000 toward Clinton's presidential primary bid from Calvin Fayard in May, 1995.20  In 2000, Hillary Rodham Clinton ran for the U.S. Senate, and according to, "Calvin Fayard D" [Calvin Fayard Jr.] of Denham Springs, Louisiana, individually contributed $11,988 to her primary campaign on Oct. 10, 2000.  Because of the legal limitation to individual contributions, it is assumed that this figure includes other members of the Fayard family.21  Caroline Fayard's individual contribution on Oct. 18, 2000, was $2,000.22

On Oct. 10, 2000, Calvin Fayard was host to a "Hillary 2000 Reception" for approximately 40 people at his private residence in Seaside, Florida, where he introduced Hillary Clinton, who spoke and responded to questions from her audience.  The affair also included a photo reception with the guests.23  Calvin Fayard is alleged to have "rented, leased and borrowed practically every car and limosine in the area to shuttle guests that flew in from all over the country on rented and leased jets and planes."24

On Sept. 1, 2004, "fund-raising of a political kind took place ... at the 'Wedding Cake House,'" the restored home of the Fayards on St. Charles Ave. in New Orleans.19  Although a complete guest list is not available, "The hosts were Danny Becnel, John Coale, Frank Dudenhefer, Walter Dumas, Glastone Jones, former Mississippi Gov. Ray Mabus, Dickie Scruggs, Hugh Sibley, and Bill Wheeler."19  Some of the hosts were Calvin Fayard's associates.  The special guest, former President Bill Clinton, remarked "that in comparison to the Fayard mansion, when he lived in Washington he lived in public housing."19  The cost of attending that Democratic Party fundraiser at the Fayard mansion with President Clinton was $10,000 a head.25  The affair made Fayard's "Wedding Cake House" look more like a "reception hall," which the tax abatement given to the home in January, 2004, prohibited.26, 27

On May 18, 2007, another private campaign fundraiser for Hillary Clinton was held at the home of the Fayards.  "An invitation ... indicates 'donors' would pay $1,000 apiece to get into the event; joining the 'host committee' cost $2,300 per person."28  The "Wedding Cake House" is owned by Andante, LLC, of Denham Springs, Louisiana, purchased in May, 2001 for $1,435,000.29  It is listed as a commercial, not a residental property in New Orleans City Council documents of tax appeals for the 2009-2010 period.30

In 2007, Hillary Clinton was the recipient of $27,600 from the Fayards when she campaigned again, this time for the U.S. presidency where the stakes were much higher.31  Calvin and five other family members each gave the maximum, $4,600.31  In August, 2008, $11,500 was returned to the Fayards, suggesting that part of the initial contribution was considered a loan.32  That same year, both Calvin Fayard and his wife Frances Gray Fayard were considered fundraisers for Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign.33 

When one considers the fund raising events that the Fayards sponsored, it is understandable why the Clintons were so accommodating when the Fayards needed their help in Caroline Fayard's race for the Louisiana Lt. Governor's position in 2010.  "Fayard used her ties to Clinton and used the former president to record robo-calls in the days leading up to the election to help get out her Democratic vote.  Clinton also appeared for her at a New York fundraiser."34  A notice of this fundraiser at the Bryant Park Hotel states that contributions are limited to $5,000 per person.35

Bill Clinton helps raise funds for Caroline Fayard
At the Sept. 7, 2010 Fundraiser for Caroline Fayard in New York City's Bryant Park Hotel35, 36, 37

(Left to right: former President Bill Clinton, Calvin C. Fayard, Jr., Cathryn Caroline Fayard)

Prior to the Sept. 7, 2010 New York City "meet-and-greet" with former President Bill Clinton, Fayard had already collected about $200,000 from individual contributors and had loaned her campaign $300,000 from her personal finances.38, 39  The loans to her campaign increased to $440,000 during the primary, and by October 21, 2010, her campaign had raised a total of about $1.3 million.40

The Duval Connection

Judge Stanwood R. Duval, Jr., a long-time friend and colleague of Calvin Fayard,41, 42 was appointed by President Bill Clinton to the federal bench of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana in 1994.43  Representative Billy Tauzin played a pivotal role in Duval's nomination for the federal judgeship.44  When asked on his appointment disclosure forms to list the names of attorneys with whom he had been involved in litigation within the last five years, Duval included Calvin Fayard, Jr. Of Denham Springs, Louisiana.45  During that period (1966-1994), Duval had been in private practice in Houma, Louisiana, and was parish attorney for the Terrebonne Parish Consolidated Government in Louisiana (1988-1993).43

Cathryn Caroline Fayard, who is Calvin Fayard's daughter by his first wife, Cynthia Sue Felder, was born in 1978 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana.  After earning a bachelor's degree in government from Dartmouth College in 2000, she worked as an "investment banking analyst" for Goldman Sachs and Company until 2002 and then went on to the University of Michigan Law School, receiving her law degree in 2005.10.  In 2004, she was a Summer Associate for the Washington, D.C. law firm, Williams and Connolly, and following her graduation from law school in 2005, she became a law clerk for her father's "good friend," Judge Duval.46  Following the one-year clerkship with Duval, she worked at the Springfield, Louisiana law firm of Fayard & Honeycutt, which is headed by her father.7, 8, 10, 31  Although Fayard states that she is in "private practice,"9, 47 she apparently has not worked independently as a lawyer without the guidance of a family member or a long-standing friend of the family.  The only public address currently found for Cathryn Caroline Fayard in Springfield is the same as her father's business address.48  The Times-Picayune of New Orleans characterized her as "a New Orleans lawyer."49  However, Fayard's campaign headquarters has stated that she is not in "private practice," nor could it furnish contact information about such practice.50  When questioned at a Dardenne/Fayard debate in Shreveport about her practice areas of law, Fayard replied, "I practice throughout the state," and I take "whatever comes in the door."3  Such equivocation about her professional work indicates a lack of candor that should make voters look closely at her eligibility for high government office.

Despite her lack of qualifications, Caroline Fayard, at the age of 32, now aspires to the second highest political position in Louisiana, that of Lieutenant Governor.51  Revelations about the ultimate sources of her campaign financing have led to speculation that Calvin Fayard is trying to buy his daughter a statewide office.52

Another of Judge Duval's recent judicial clerks is Ravi Sangisetty, who also has developed political aspirations.  Sangisetty's legal work has centered on post-Katrina litigation involving Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), homeowners insurance, and the National Flood Insurance Progam.  Not only does he and his family live in Houma, Louisiana, but he now works for Duval, Funderburk, Sundbery, et al., the former law firm of Judge Duval, now headed by the judge's brother, C. Berwick Duval.  Sangisetty is seeking to occupy the House seat vacated by Representative Charlie Melancon of Louisiana's Third Congressional District.53, 54  Among Sangisetty's top contributors during the 2009-2010 election cycle were Duval, Funderburk et al. ($10,100), Duval & Shearer and Duval Funderburk (each $4,800), Fayard & Honeycutt ($4,150), and Sangisetty for Congress ($3,450)55  Caroline Fayard also contributed $2,650 to the Sangisetty campaign56 as did Judge Duval's sister-in-law, Alexis A. Duval, who gave $4,800.57  The financial contributions to the Fayard and Sangisetty campaigns point to an apparent effort by the Duvals, Fayards, and Clintons to enhance their political power base in Louisiana.

Caroline Fayard58 and Ravi Sangisetty59 have both made it to the run-offs that will be held on election day, November 2, 2010.

Carl Bernofsky
October 8, 2010
Revised November 3, 2010

Election Outcome

Caroline Fayard lost the election to her opponent, Republican Jay Dardenne, who received 57% of the vote to Fayard's 43%.60  More striking is that Fayard received only 24% of the vote in Livingston Parish, in which her home town of Denham Springs is located.61  Dardenne, an experienced public servant and currently Secretary of State, had not been endorsed by either Louisiana's Republican Governor, Bobby Jindal, or State Republican Party Chairman, Roger Villere.60

Ravi Sangisetty lost the election to his opponent, Republican "Jeff" Landry, who received 64% of the vote to Sangisetty's 36%.62


The research and insights of Shirley Bernofsky are gratefully acknowledged.  Corrections and suggestions should be addressed to the author at


  1. Caroline Fayard for Lieutenant Governor," Facebook. Accessed 4 Oct 2010.

  2. Marsha Shuler, "Fayard Banking on Fresh Approach, Not Party Affiliation, in Nov. Runoff," The Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) 19 Oct 2010, P. 01A, Capitol News Bureau News.

  3. Dardenne/Fayard Debate at the Broadmoor Presbyterian Church in Shreveport, attended by author, 19 Oct 2010.

  4. Capitol News Bureau, "Appointees *** Foster Still Making Choices to Fill Department Secretary, Other Posts," The Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) 7 Jan 1996, P. 5-G, News.

  5. "Bobby Jindal," Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 20 Oct 2010.  Note that Wikipedia cites Jindal as Louisiana's health secretary at 25 and the state university system's president at 28.

  6. Marsha Shuler, "Jindal to Take over College System," The Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) 8 May 1999, P. 1B 2B, News.

  7. Caroline Fayard, " A Message from Caroline" and "A Brief Biography," About Caroline - Caroline for Lieutenant Governor. Accessed 17 Aug 2010.

  8. Submitted by FrancesGry [Frances Gray Fayard], "Why Not a Woman for Lt. Governor," Krewe of Truth, 15 Jul 2010.|QP=2. Accessed 15 Sep 2010.

  9. Ken Benitez, ActionNews17, "Caroline Fayard," YouTube Video. 19 Sep 2010. Accessed 5 Oct 2010.

  10. Ed Anderson, "The Candidates [for] Lieutenant Governor," Caroline Fayard, The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 15 Sep 2010, P. A04, National.

  11. Open, Center for Responsive Politics, Donor: Fayard, Recipient: Billy Tauzin, Search: All Cycles. Accessed 20 Apr 2010. See also: Newsmeat, "Fayard's Federal Campaign Contribution Search Results". Accessed 22 Apr 2010.

  12. Loyola University of New Orleans, "Emerging Legal Scholarship: The Westerfield Fellows Inaugural Workshops". See: 25 Mar 2010 of Calendar shown. Accessed 4 Oct 2010.

  13. Loyola University of New Orleans, "Westerfield Fellows". Accessed 4 Oct 2010.

  14. Loyola University of New Orleans, "Society of St. Ignatius". Accessed 4 Oct 2010

  15. "Personal Financial Disclosure, 'Tier 1', LSA-R.S. 42:1124". 2009 Personal Financial Disclosure for 10/02/10 Election. Accessed 26 Aug 2010. See also: Marsha Shuler, "Hopefuls Release Financial Reports". The Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) 24 Jul 2010, P. 1A, Capitol News Bureau News Section. See also: "Safari Investments, LLC," Louisiana Secretary of State, Louisiana Corporations Database. Accessed 11 Jan 2010.

  16. Louisiana Secretary of State, Louisiana Corporations Database. "Safari Investments, LLC". Accessed 14 Apr 2010. See also: "Owner Information" for Video Poker: Lucky Dollar Casino. Accessed 26 Aug 2010.

  17. "Minutes of June 18, 2002," Louisiana Gaming Control Board.$FILE/Minutes061802.pdf. Accessed 9 Sep 2010.

  18. Louisiana Secretary of State, Louisiana Corporations Database. "Arbor Towne, LLC". and "Felyard Investment Group, LLC".

  19. Nell Nolan, "Awards Dinner and Celebrity Waiters' Lunch," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 7 Sep 2004, P. 02, Living.

  20. Newsmeat, Campaign Contribution Search, "Calvin Fayard" in Denham. Accessed 6 Oct 2010.

  21. "Hillary Rodham Clinton," United States Senate Political Campaign Contributions, Campaign Finance Information, '00 Cycle. Accessed 15 Sep 2010.

  22. Newsmeat, Campaign Contribution Search, "Cathryn Fayard". Accessed 6 Oct 2010.

  23. "Hillary Clinton's Activities as First Lady, 1993-2001", Schedule for Hillary Rodham Clinton, Tuesday, October 10, 2000, The Washington Post (Washington, D.C.) 2008, P. 16707. Accessed 26 Aug 2010.

  24. Pseudonym: Not at All Surprised, Comments regarding "A Foti Friend in Camp Clinton - Updated," 20 Mar 2008. Accessed 31 Jul 2010.

  25. Mark Waller and Frank Donze, "Clinton's Book Tour Hits New Orleans - 'My Life' Author Draws Huge Crowd of Adoring Fans," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 2 Sep 2004, P.02, National.

  26. Bruce Eggler, "1890s Mansion Wins Tax Break - Council's Approval Bucks Trend in N.O." The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 16 Jan 2004. P. 01, Metro.

  27. Bruce Eggler, "Quest to Rein in City Tax Breaks Finds Opposition - Exemption Renewal Important to Storage Business, Owner Says", The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 26 Dec 2003, P. 01, Metro.

  28. Michelle Krupa, "Clinton Offers Recovery Agenda - Seed Money Now Would Cut Red Tape," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 19 May 2007, P.01, Metro.

  29. City of New Orleans, Property Viewer, "5809 St. Charles Ave." Accessed 18 Jan 2010.

  30. New Orleans City Council, Tax Appeals Schedule. Accessed 6 Oct 2010.

  31. "Who's Donating", Fayard Family Contributions and Donations, Huffington Post Fundrace. Accessed 15 Sep 2010.

  32., “Find Contributions,” Hillary Clinton - All Races, All Cycles, Fayard Surname. Accessed 25 Aug 2010.

  33. "2008 Hillary Rodham Clinton Presidential Campaign", Muckety Listings. Accessed 25 Aug 2010.

  34. Ed Anderson, "Dardenne, Fayard to Vie for Lieutenant Governor – Familiar Face, Newcomer in Runoff," The Times-Picayune (Orleans, LA) 3 Oct 2010, P. A09, National.

  35. Committee to Elect Caroline Fayard, "Caroline Fayard for Lieutenant Governor," Invitation for a reception and fundraiser with President Bill Clinton, (clintoninvite-1.doc) Accessed 15 Sep 2010.

  36. "Former President Bill Clinton in Support of Caroline Fayard for Louisiana Lt. Governor", A YouTubeVideo, 7 Sep 2010. Accessed 11 Sep 2010.

  37. Caroline Fayard for Lieutenant Governor, "Clinton Fundraiser," Facebook. Accessed 7 Oct 2010.

  38. Times-Picayune Staff, "Lieutenant Governor Campaign Finance Reports Contain Some Surprises," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 4 Sep 2010. Accessed 4 Sep 2010.

  39. Jeremy Alford, "The Race for Lieutenant Governor," Best of New and Gambit, 20 Sep 2010. Accessed 20 Sep 2010.

  40. Ed Anderson and Jan Moller, "State GOP Official Holding Tight to Purse Strings - Also: Conservative Publisher Withholds Endorsement in Senate Race," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 21, Oct 2010, A01, National.

  41. Stanwood R. Duval, Jr., U.S. District Judge, Eastern District of Louisiana, AO-10 Financial Disclosure Report for 2007, Administrative Office of the United States Courts.  See also: Carl Bernofsky, "Judicial Non-Disclosure as Disclosure; Avoidance of full disclosure is the latest trend," Accessed 07 Oct 2010.

  42. Carl Bernofsky, "Scoring a Touchdown with the Judge," 31 Mar 2010, Accessed 07 Oct 2010.

  43. "Stanwood R. Duval, Jr.," Biographical Directory of Federal Judges, Federal Judical Center. Accessed 29 Mar 2010.

  44. "Claude B. Duval," Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, The Wikipedia Foundation, Inc., Accessed 4 Apr 2010.

  45. Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, One Hundred Third Congress, "Confirmation Hearings on Federal Appointments - S. Hrg. 103-1031, Pt. 5", Second Session on Confirmation of Appointees to the Federal Judiciary, Aug. 17, 18, 25; Sept. 14 and 21, 1994. P. 512. Accessed 14 Apr 2010.

  46. University of Michigan Law School, "Appendix A: Michigan Alumni Who Have Clerked and Students with Future Clerkships". Accessed 4 Oct 2010.

  47. Project Vote Smart, "Caroline Fayard (LA)". Accessed 5 Sep 2010.

  48. "Cathryn Caroline Fayard," Legal Issue or Lawyer/Firm Name, Justia. Accessed 8 Oct 2010. See also: "Fayard Calvin C" Find Business Attorneys in Springfield, LA, 19 Jan 2010.

  49. Ed Anderson, "Race for State's No. 2 Office Heats Up - Dardenne, Fayard Start Trading Barbs," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 18 Oct 2010, A01, National.

  50. Personal Communication from Gina Gatewood and "Kelly" at Caroline Fayard's New Orleans campaign headquarters. 8 Oct 2010.

  51. Scott McKay (MacAoidh), "Fayard Doesn't Seem to Have a Clue What Job She's Running For," The Hayride, Posted on 22 Sep 2010. Accessed 27 Sep 2010.

  52. Scott McKay (MacAoidh), "Potential Bombshell In Lt. Gov. Race - Is Fayard Laundering Family Cash Through La. Dem Party?" The Hayride, Posted on 27 Oct 2010. Accessed 27 Oct 2010.  See also: Ed Anderson, "State Democratic Group Sends Fayard $200,000 - Names of Donors Were Not Reported," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 2 Nov 2010, P. A02, National.

  53. "About Ravi," and "Houma's Sangisetty Enters 3rd Cong. District Race," Ravi Sangisetty: U.S. Congress Third District website. Accessed 19 Sep 2010.

  54. "It's Time to Decide: Voters Go to Polls; 2 Parish Presidents among the Contests," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 2 Oct 2010, P. A01, National.

  55. "Top 20 Contributors" Ravi Sangisetty, Open Center for Responsive Politics. Accessed 26 Sep 2010.

  56. Newsmeat, Campaign Contribution Search, "Cathryn Fayard". Accessed 6 Oct 2010.

  57. Newsmeat, "Campaign Contribution Search," Ravi Sangisetty, by Alexis Duval. Accessed 7 Oct 2010.

  58. Ed Anderson, "Dardenne, Fayard Forge Ahead for Edge in Runoff for Lieutenant Governor - None of Runners-up Endorses a Survivor," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 5 Oct 2010, P. A02, National.

  59. Gerard Shields, "Landry Defeats Downer in Election in 3rd District," The Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA) 3 Oct 2010, P. 05A, Advocate Washington Bureau News Section.

  60. Ed Anderson, "Dardenne Tops Fayard in Lieutenant Governor Race - He Rolls Up Big Victory after Tense Campaign," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 3 Nov 2010, P. A14, National.

  61. "Lieutenant Governor," Louisiana Secretary of State,, accessed 3 Nov 2010.

  62. "U.S. House Races in Louisiana - Election Returns," The Times-Picayune (New Orleans, LA) 3 Nov 2010, P. A104, National.