STATEWIDE BALLOT INITIATIVES
and the
Judicial Accountability Initiative Law (J.A.I.L.)

INNS OF COURT JUDICIAL REFORM ABOUT J.A.I.L. ABOUT INITIATIVES AMENDMENT E VIEWS & NEWS SIGN PETITION TULANELINK


KELO-TV Poll: Judicial Accountability
 
MATT BELANGER
 
November 4, 2006
 

On Tuesday, South Dakota voters will choose whether to open up decision makers to lawsuits and hold them financially accountable for their actions.  We can break down how voters are viewing Amendment E with the results from our KELO-TV poll.

Debate continues over who would be held accountable if Amendment E passes.  Those opposed say it will make many decision makers in the community vunerable.

"Anyone elected up who makes judicial decisions or quasi-legislative decision will be open to lawsuit through personal assets, and quite frankly I believe it will be very difficult to find qualified people in the future to run for these positions if they're going to open themselves up to civil liability because of the decisions they made," said Garry Moore who opposes the amendment.

Those who support the issue say the constitutional amendment is only designed to hold judges accountable.

William Stegmeier
 
William Stegmeier

"County commissions, school boards, they're sued all the time; and judges are the only element of society that are immune from any kind of suit, for even malicious and corrupt acts.  If a county commission or school board breaks the law and commits a deliberate violation, they're going to be sued and they're going to be prosecuted.  Judges are the only facit of society that are immune, and we have a unique opportunity here in South Dakota to once again pave the way for something good like this," said William Stegmeier who supports Amendment E.

 

According to KELO-TV's poll results, 51 percent of all voters say they'd vote yes on Amendment E if the election was held today.  Forty percent said they'd vote no, and 9 percent were undecided.

More women than men support the amendment when you break down the results by gender.

And when you look at the results divided by political party, you can see more Democrats support the amendment than Republicans.

 
Copyright 2006, KELO-TV — KELOLAND.COM
 

From: KELO-TV, November 4, 2006, Sioux Falls, South Dakota, http://www.keloland.com/newsdetail6162.cfm?id=0,52205, accessed November 10, 2006.  Reprinted in accordance with the "fair use" provision of Title 17 U.S.C. § 107 for a non-profit educational purpose.


INNS OF COURT JUDICIAL REFORM ABOUT J.A.I.L. ABOUT INITIATIVES AMENDMENT E VIEWS & NEWS SIGN PETITION TULANELINK


This Web site is not associated with Tulane University or its affiliates

© 1998-2015 Carl Bernofsky - All rights reserved
tulanelink@aol.com